
Here are some critic reviews of the new self-titled Scars on Broadway album.
ARTISTDirect"Is this the end or a rebirth?" Daron Malakian asks during "Universe," a track from Scars On Broadway's self-titled debut. However, there's a more important question that needs to be asked. With that line, is Malakian referencing the end of his metallic juggernaut System of a Down, or is he talking about the end of something more cosmic? Only he knows the answer, but it probably involves a little bit of both. There are some big issues on his mind, and that's instantly apparent from the first note of this album. Scars dive deep into the seedy Hollywood underbelly that System only touched upon during their last two offerings. Malakian feels at home surrounded by freaks, but his sonic freakshow's quite entertaining. "Funny" broods with woozy instrumental textures and electronic flourishes. Malakian's stoned, creepy wail dominates the track's massive hook, enveloping the calculated clean guitar rhythm. In a nutshell, Scars have crafted the first great psychedelic rock release of 2008. John Lennon's influence is all over the choruses of "World Long Gone," "Babylon" and the aforementioned "Universe." However, Malakian adds an edge. He's grown into himself as a singer, and that comes through on all of the more melodic fare. In fact, he's almost more "Silverlake-Indie" than he is "Hollywood-Gutter Rock." Regardless, he's crafted some intriguing rock and roll gems.The standout tracks showcase his musical schizophrenia. A serpentine riff drives "Exploding/Reloading" right off the rails once Malakian starts screaming, "I Like Suicide." However, the song still has that big ole hummable hook. The combination of "Chemicals" and "Enemy" are strange and devilishly inviting metal with some fantastically fun chemical references. Nodding a black-brimmed hat to the '60s, this is rock 'n roll in its purest form. "Stoner-Hate" brandishes another razor sharp riff and more of that kooky screaming, but the song hits like a sledgehammer. Rhythmic sensei John Dolmayan is bashing away at those big grooves behind the kit. His pounding is as zen as ever, keeping the tracks grounded. Then there's "Cute Machines" one of the album's deepest cuts. The track mashes up all of the styles that the band excels at. A bombastic drum beat kicks the song off and propels a staccato riff in synch with the big sing-song melody.Meanwhile, "3005" shouts out Jesus Christ and Charles Manson, both of whom figure integrally on this record. The album winds up on "Whoring Streets," another dark trip down Hollywood's alleys. First single "They Say" concludes everything. Malakian strums his guitar somberly as everything ends. No matter how you cut it, eulogizing the end of the world is quite a way to finish a record. To answer Malakian's big question, this isn't the end after all. This is the start of something, and it could be VERY important.—Rick Florino07.27.08About.comScars on Broadway, the self-titled debut album from
System of a Down guitarist Daron Malakian and drummer John Dolmayan, is a mixed bag of terrific songs and forgettable filler. Totaling 15 tracks – many of them running three minutes or less – the album resembles a collection of snippets, sometimes evolving into indelibly melodic hard rock and sometimes failing to leave much of an impact. A tougher trimming would have helped Scars on Broadway’s overall quality, but even in its current form the record has enough strong moments to make it worthwhile.
Lyrics Less Important Than HooksIn an interview to promote Scars on Broadway, frontman Daron Malakian confessed that as a songwriter he doesn’t have any grand thematic concepts or personal messages he’s trying to push across in his lyrics. That certainly comes through on the album, where lyrical depth takes a backseat to his melodies and hooks. For example, the hard-charging two-minute “Stoner-Hate” contains such odd lines as “California’s been invaded by a hippie psychopath,” which doesn’t make much sense – Does he mean
Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger? – but becomes a compelling chant when it’s attached to Malakian’s guitar riff and Dolmayan’s pounding drums. Especially considered in conjunction with the brief running times of these songs, many of the tracks have an off-the-cuff feel, which perhaps is a way of alleviating the weighty expectations of many System fans who want to hear what Malakian would do outside of his old band’s framework.
Taking Aim at Politicians and the GreedyWith that said, though, when Scars on Broadway find a great piece of music, the tossed-off lyrics have the impact of desperate missives hurled at politicians and those who despoil the planet for their own greed. “Kill Each Other/Live Forever” is a good example of this, segueing from guitars to an affecting keyboard bridge while Malakian assumes the mantle of public conscience as he asks, “If we’re gonna kill each other, how we gonna live forever/If we’re gonna live forever, how we gonna kill each other?” The point of the lyrics seems to be juxtaposing two base human urges – the desire to kill others and the desire to never die yourself – to show how they simply cannot coexist in a civilized society.
Rocking While The World Falls ApartMuch of Scars on Broadway makes similar allusions to a world crumbling into disarray. “Babylon” starts off slowly until building to a frenetic chorus, balancing an Armageddon scenario with a tale of separated lovers. “Cute Machines” rides a snarling guitar figure for an opaque attack on technology – then again, it might simply be a satire on the dehumanizing aspects of modern society.
Part of the fun is not necessarily being able to pin down the exact meanings of Malakian’s words, which doesn’t matter when his band has arresting music to focus on. And while that doesn’t happen enough – a few too many of these tracks feel like underdeveloped outtakes – Scars on Broadway displays enough passion and chops to satisfy even those who will grumble that it’s not a System of a Down record. Maybe, but for a guy who claims he doesn’t have much to say, Malakian makes sure his music speaks for him.
Release date – July 29, 2008
Rolling StoneWhen you've made your name and fortune on fierce weirdness, the most drastic thing you can do is flaunt some restraint. In System of a Down, singer-guitarist Daron Malakian's bright yelp was already the more normal voice next to Serj Tankian's operatic harangue. But as Scars on Broadway, with System drummer John Dolmayan, Malakian shaves System's punk-dervish and metallic-vengeance extremes into straight-on rock glazed with New Wave keyboards and impish-angel harmonies. It is a cleverly barbed normality. "Funny" is a catchy death wish that somehow evokes Roy Orbison's "Oh, Pretty Woman" amid burbling Eighties synthesizer. "Insane" is steady, rolling darkness with a Who-ish splash of power chords at the end of each verse. There is little hope or redemption in Malakian's writing — "Chemicals" is a portrait of vicious co-dependency — and his rage, irony and expletives sometimes overwhelm the music's simplified sparkle and drive. That doesn't happen in the bullet rock, hairpin turns and minimal chant of "Cute Machines." The song is basically nonsense — and a fine, uncomplicated high.KROQ:
I've got some pretty good speakers in my car - not killer - we're not talking about a hearse with coffins full of woofers - but it can handle the BOOM and the new self titled Scars on Broadway album (out July 29th) gives them a bumpin', loud, healthy work out. In fact, track 13 - CUTE MACHINES, may have caused some permanent damage. Hey, if the 'Kardons have gotta go, why not make their swan song something really off that wall referencing both Babylon and our own beloved City of Angels? System of a Down (like Queens of the Stone Age) come at rock from a different side of the stage - from very different perspectives than most bands - making them one of KROQ's best bands ever - and they were at the top of their game when experimenting with new beats and textures. Scars expand that search and, oddly (unlike MOST bands) are at their best when taking themselves pretty seriously (like in the sick good new cuts WORLD LONG GONE and INSANE). It's a little easier to keep BABYLON cranked than when Scars are horsing around a bit and rhyming Mary Poppins' favorite word Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious (and, yes, I spelled that right without Spell Check).
This is one of those albums that really flows, too. The songs are short and tight (not toit, btw) and each one makes the next one make more sense in a sonic way. Scars have quite the obsession with Jesus and no qualms about trying out what different instruments sound like bumped up next to each other and doing their best to keep up with some crazy beats - so overall you're in for some damn good s***.
My Personal Review (Song by Song):
Serious: A great way to open the album. Very catchy and has a nice melody. It is a nice combination of a slow melody and a hard chorus. Rating: 9/10
Funny: Also a nice song. Lyrics are very good. But to really get it, you have to know about the swastikas on the pole in Broadway. Rating: 9/10
Exploding/Reloading: Probably my second favorite song on the album. I really enjoy Daron's voice in this song. I prefer the title "I Like Suicide" but I guess they couldn't use that. Rating: 10/10
Stoner-Hate: The song that sounds most like System, IMO. Another great song with cool lyrics. And the story behind the song (Daron's imaginary gang of angry hippies) is even better. Rating: 10/10
Insane: Not one of the strong songs on the album, but good nonetheless. A little repetitive, but the solo and Daron's beautiful voice in this song saved it from just being an "OK" song. Rating: 7/10
World Long Gone: Another song that sounds like System. Very good riffs. And once again, Daron's voice is awesome. Rating: 8/10
Kill Each Other/Live Forever: I really enjoy this song. Lyrics are very good and catchy. Guitar is awesome. Drums are awesome. Everything is awesome. Rating: 9/10
Babylon: Probably my favorite song off the album. It sounds so much like DAM, but that's not why I like it. It starts off very slow and quiet, but just like that, it hits hard. Daron's voice is, once again, beautiful in this song and the lyrics are even better. Rating: 10/10
Chemicals: Most likely my least favorite song. It just sounds so different from the other songs. Daron's voice changes dramatically as compared to Babylon. The first few words just sound so weird when he says them. But, the drums are awesome. Just not my favorite song. Rating: 6/10
Enemy: Another great song. The highlight was of coarse "Drugs" But, that's probably the same with all System fans. I like the intro riff used throughout the whole song, very catchy. It's just a song that I can bounce to. Rating: 9/10
Universe: I enjoy this song. Lyrics are very good. Daron's voice is great. Guitar riffs are great. Solo is awesome as well. Great song. Rating: 9/10
3005: Another weak point in the album, IMO. It just doesn't sound like a song Scars would write based on the lyrics. It sounds too much like a modern "rock" band. The one thing I can say is that the "Charlie Manson" thing was pretty cool. Rating: 7/10
Cute Machines: I love the guitar in this song. I personally like this song better live, but it still great. Lyrics are a little repetitive, but still awesome. Rating: 8/10
Whoring Streets: Another favorite of mine. It was my favorite song @ KROQ and it's still awesome. Lyrics are really catchy and the solo is awesome as well. It's probably the most beautiful song on the album. Rating: 10/10
They Say: It's the first song from Scars. Gotta love it. Guitar is simple, but effective. Lyrics are awesome. Drums are cool as well. Catchy song. Rating: 9/10
Hungry Ghost: A little bonus here. I really enjoy this song. It's so creepy. I've said before that this belongs on The Mummy 3 soundtrack. It would fit perfect. Daron's voice is so cool and sounds creepy. I hear Holy Mountains throughout the song and that makes it even better. Rating: 9/10
Overall rating: 9/10